Metabolic Intro Series - Part 2
Two Theories
Though most people aren’t aware of it, there have been two major competing theories of health running for about the last 150 years, one of them based on genes and genetics, and the other based on cellular metabolism and energy.
In this video I break down the differences between them and where they both point us towards.
Resources - Beginners
Reading
It All Comes Down to Energy - Article by Jay Feldman on the importance of energy and why energy is the thing that connects health and disease.
I Survived Cancer and so Can You - Article by Nathan Hatch on curing his thyroid cancer and explaining why it worked.
Listening/Watching
Another View of Evolution - Danny Roddy and Georgi Dinkov discussing the two opposing views of evolution.
Lamarck vs Drawin - Useful video by BrainGenie on the differences between Darwin and Lamarck.
FAQ’s
-
Good question - and of course neither I nor metabolic theory are suggesting that genes do not matter - Genes are certainly involved in inheritance and passing on of information without a doubt.
However, the suggestion from myself and from metabolic theory is that, though genes may pass on information from one generation to the next, it is the environment, including our food, stress levels, and living conditions, which determines our health, and also that a life lived with plenty of energy and good environment can pass changes down to our offspring in both a genetic and non genetic way.
-
This is actually a common misconception - The Neo-Darwinists managed to change the way many of us now understand Darwins natural selection - but in fact Drawin himself was a confirmed "Lamarckist", which you can find well documented in various places including here - academic.oup.com/ije/article/45/6/2206/2617243
-
So my basic understanding is that they are both essentially states of lower energy availability, and that one of them is perhaps more advanced than the other. This is where we might say that your genes come into the picture - yes you might have what we could call a "genetic" predisposition to depression, in that perhaps your brain is not functioning as optimally as in a "healthy" person, but it is still very much your environment and energy which determine whether or not you ever get depression, and, conversely, increasing your energy stores and use can cure the depression.
For someone with cancer metabolic theory would suggest that the energetic deficit is simply far greater, to the point of which the cells involved are so starved of energy that they have had to dismantle their structure in order to survive...but it has been shown that even cancer cells can become normal cells again given enough energy.
haidut.me/?p=1668
-
Well...not exactly...They are both related in the sense of both being "low energy" problems, but you would work with them differently depending on your current circumstances, individual history, and context.
Both of them might benefit from large amounts of the b vitamins which are heavily involved in restoring proper energy for instance, but whilst low libido might just require a dietary shift and looking at macronutrients and fat soluble vitamins, cancer might require a much stronger approach using protective hormones, thyroid, and other regenerative substances.
Resources - Science Minded
Reading
Adaptive Substance, Creative Regeneration - Article by Dr. Ray Peat on the problems with the genetic/Neo-Darwinistic approach.
Mitochondria and Mortality - Article by Dr.Ray Peat on the importance of mitochondria, energy, and carbon dioxide.
Cancer as a Metabolic Disease - Article by Thomas Seyfreid on cancer as its associations with metabolism.
A Unified Theory of Evolution - Article by Professor Michael Skinner on the combination of theories from both Darwin and Lamarck
Listening
Another view of Evolution - Danny Roddy and Georgi Dinkov discussing the two opposing views of evolution.
The Association Induction Hypothesis - Danny Roddy talking about the work of Gilbert Ling and why our current view of the cell might be wrong.
Lamarck Reloaded - Professor Peter Smith on TED talking about Epigenetics and how Lamarck’s theory impacts us today.
Origins and Lamarck - Dr. Ray Peat on the Primitive Initiative podcast talking about the Lamarckian view of evolution as well as extras.